The Thoughts
Essays
Written for people working in music and the arts. On institutions, incentives, tradition, technology and the stories we tell ourselves about all of them. Some begin with the record; others begin at the desk where the record is administered.
Note 01 / 02
The Myth of the Isolated Work: Disputed AI Copyrights In Broader Entertainment Ecosystems
Debates about AI-generated music often focus on whether a particular output deserves copyright protection. Far less attention is paid to the larger structures that surround commercial works. A song is rarely just a song. It is branding, reputation, trademarks, contracts, and goodwill woven together into something far more complex than a single file.
Read the note2 notes in the archive
- The Myth of the Isolated Work: Disputed AI Copyrights In Broader Entertainment EcosystemsDebates about AI-generated music often focus on whether a particular output deserves copyright protection. Far less attention is paid to the larger structures that surround commercial works. A song is rarely just a song. It is branding, reputation, trademarks, contracts, and goodwill woven together into something far more complex than a single file.Read
- The Danger of Half-Measures: TIDAL, AI Music, and the Cost of Premature CertaintyTIDAL’s decision to host AI-generated music while denying royalties reflects a broader trend of institutions adopting moral positions before the legal and economic implications are settled. If content remains valuable enough to distribute, stream, and monetise, questions inevitably arise about the basis for withholding compensation from its creators.Read