Essay
The Danger of Half-Measures: TIDAL, AI Music, and the Cost of Premature Certainty
TIDAL’s decision to host AI-generated music while denying royalties reflects a broader trend of institutions adopting moral positions before the legal and economic implications are settled. If content remains valuable enough to distribute, stream, and monetise, questions inevitably arise about the basis for withholding compensation from its creators.
In June 2026, TIDAL announced a new policy regarding AI-generated music. The platform chose not to ban the material outright. Instead, it declared that music identified as wholly AI-generated would remain available on the service while becoming ineligible for royalties. Tracks would be labelled, hosted, streamed, and promoted through the platform, yet their creators would receive no compensation from those streams.
The decision was presented as a way to protect artists and ensure that royalties flow toward works created by human beings. TIDAL also described the policy as part of a broader effort to improve transparency and combat fraud.
The problem is that the policy reflects a broader tendency that frequently emerges whenever a new technology arrives: institutions rush to establish a moral position, one often tainted by their own financial interests, before the legal, commercial, and practical realities have fully matured.
History contains countless examples of technologies that were initially dismissed as frivolous or culturally corrosive before eventually becoming ordinary tools.
Many of those criticisms contained elements of truth. Emerging technologies often attract opportunists. They reduce barriers to entry. They create fresh opportunities for spam, fraud, low-effort content, and misleading business practices. AI is no exception. The current flood of automated uploads, impersonation schemes, and mass-produced content is a legitimate concern.
Yet the existence of bad uses does not resolve the questions surrounding legitimate uses, or further, uses which have additional legal or structural consideration due to their very nature of existing as a work in our world.
If an artist uses AI tools in the production of a song, owns the underlying copyrights, controls the trademarks, manages the branding, and distributes the recording legally, a streaming platform is still deriving value from making that work available to subscribers. If that same platform continues to host the music, benefits from its presence in the catalogue, and potentially uses engagement data generated by that content, the question becomes difficult to avoid: on what basis should the platform refuse compensation while continuing to exploit the commercial value of the work?
This is where moral positioning starts colliding with legal reality.
Copyright law is not primarily concerned with whether observers approve of the creative process. Trademark law is not contingent upon whether critics find a technology tasteful. Ownership interests continue to exist whether a work was created with a paintbrush, a camera, a synthesizer, a computer program, or a machine learning model. The debate over the scope of those rights remains active, but rights do not disappear merely because an institution wishes to signal opposition to a particular technology. That creates a potentially awkward position for a platform like TIDAL.
If AI-generated music is viewed as fundamentally illegitimate, then complete removal is the cleaner and more internally consistent policy. The platform would eliminate both the content and the associated obligations. Users could disagree with the decision, but the position would at least be coherent.
Instead, TIDAL has chosen a middle ground that preserves the benefits of hosting the music while attempting to eliminate payment.
Such a policy invites questions that courts, regulators, and rightsholders may eventually have to answer. The uncertainty becomes even greater because the technology itself remains in an early stage. TIDAL's policy openly acknowledges that detection methods are still evolving and that future classifications may expand as its systems improve.
That admission is significant. Whenever compensation depends upon classification, classification errors create financial consequences. A falsely identified track is no longer merely mislabelled. It may be deprived of revenue. Disputes over ownership, attribution, and royalties become substantially more serious when money is attached to the decision-making process.
This is why snap decisions carry risks that extend far beyond public perception. An institution can survive accusations that it moved too slowly. Recovering from legal disputes, contractual conflicts, or allegations of unequal treatment is often far more difficult.
The deeper issue concerns the assumption that the future shape of AI creation is already known.
At present, much AI-generated content is indeed low effort. Some of it is deceptive. Some of it exists solely to chase algorithmic engagement.
The same observation could be made about a tremendous quantity of human-generated content as well.
Technological capability tends to improve faster than institutional predictions. The tools available today are unlikely to represent the tools available in five years. Creative professionals will continue integrating AI into workflows. New genres will emerge. New business models will emerge. New legal frameworks will emerge. Some of the most significant future works created with AI assistance likely have not even been conceived yet.
Policies driven primarily by moral enthusiasm frequently age poorly because they are constructed around present perceptions rather than future realities.
As I have observed in my capacity as creative director of Torii House Phonograph Co., the practical consequences of these constantly shifting standards are often ignored. Artists and labels already navigate an increasingly fragmented digital landscape where every platform has different requirements, different classifications, and different ideological preferences. The result becomes an expanding administrative burden as creators attempt to track which company accepts which technologies under which conditions at any given moment.
That burden does not create better music. It creates paperwork and it creates uncertainty.
And it creates incentive structures that favour large organizations with compliance departments over independent creators attempting to navigate an evolving marketplace.
Ultimately, the strongest argument against TIDAL's approach is not that AI-generated music is morally acceptable or morally unacceptable. Those debates will continue for years. Sensible people will disagree. Markets, courts, legislators, creators, and audiences will all have their own perspectives.
The stronger criticism is that the company appears to have selected a position that inherits risks from both sides. It keeps the content. It keeps the streams. It keeps the catalogue. Yet it attempts to exclude compensation.
That arrangement may satisfy a short-term desire to draw a hard line during a period of public controversy. Whether it remains sustainable once ownership claims, licensing structures, and future legal precedents mature is another question entirely.
Truth does not become less truthful because a machine helped write it. Consequences do not cease to exist because a computer participated in producing them. Reality remains indifferent to the method of creation. A statement is either correct or incorrect. A right either exists or it does not. A legal obligation either applies or it does not.
Institutions that rush toward moral certainty before those underlying questions are settled often discover that reality has a habit of arriving later with a much larger invoice.